SSA / IRS Employment Tax Forms
Published August 2011 | Revised January 6, 2025
by L. Kenway BComm CPB Retired
WHAT'S IN THIS ARTICLE
SSA / IRS Tax Information Slips and Returns | Form W-4 | Form W-2 | Form W-3 | Small Business Year-End Payroll Tasks | Yearend Payroll Checklist | Independent Contractors | Final Thoughts
There is usually a lot of stress and confusion that comes with year-end payroll processing. While December brings lots of holiday cheer, it also brings payroll responsibilities that can't be overlooked. In this chat, I've broken down what you need to do throughout the year as well as what you need to know about the various SSA / IRS employment tax forms to close out your payroll year successfully.
This chat is written for small businesses with less than 10 employees. So pour yourself a cup a tea, settle in ... relax ... and let's get started.
Table of Contents
U.S. Employment Tax Forms W2, W3, W4, I-9
1. SSA / IRS Tax Information Slips and Returns - Definition
2. Form W-4 The Starting Point
- I-9 New Hire Paperwork
- Best Practices for New Hires
3. Form W-2 The Annual Employee Wage Statement
- Supplemental Wages
- Yearend W-2 Reconciliation
4. Form W-3 The Transmittal Form
- Yearend W-3 Reconciliation
5. Reconciliation Tips
6. Red Flags To Watch For
Small Business Year-End Payroll Tasks
1. Understanding Key Deadlines
2. Verify Employee Information
3. Review Wage and Tax Data
4. Process Final Payroll Adjustments
5. Prepare for the New Year
6. Data Backup
7. Best Practices
8. Additional Important Steps to Consider
9. Cautionary Note
10. Common Pitfalls to Avoid
11. Getting Help When Needed
12. Reliable Sources for Checklists
Small Business Year-End Payroll Checklist
1. Verify Employee Information and Classification
2. Reconcile Payroll Records
3. Tax Compliance and Reconciliation
4. Benefits Review
5. Year-end Tax Forms
6. System Updates for New Year
7. Record Keeping
My Recommendations For Independent Contractors
Final Thoughts
INDEX for Federal Payroll Taxes Series
U.S. Employment Tax Forms W2, W3, W4, I-9
SSA / IRS Tax Information Slips and Returns
Wondering what an information return is?
According to the law dictionary at law.yourdictionary.com, it is "a tax return intended to communicate information about the taxpayer’s activities or status to the Internal Revenue Service, but upon which no tax is due".
It's a fancy way of saying it provides tax information but does not compute tax due.
Employment Tax Form W-4 The Starting Point
Quick Overview:
- Every new employee must complete this tax form BEFORE their first paycheck.
- The tax form tells you how much tax to withhold from their paychecks.
- Get this signed on day one along with I-9 employment verification.
- Keep these forms in a secure employee file.
- If an employee wants to change their withholding, they submit a new W-4.
Admin Alert: If you are hiring an independent contractor, the process is a bit different.
Tax Compliance
Undeliverable Tax Forms
The IRS requires employers to keep all employment tax records for at least 4 years after the due date of the employee's personal income tax return OR after the tax is paid, whichever is later. This includes:
- Employee's W-4 forms
- Forms 941 (Quarterly Tax Returns)
- Forms 943, 944, 945 (if applicable)
- Form W-3 (Transmittal of Wage Statements)
- Copy A of Forms W-2
- Undeliverable W-2s*
*If you can electronically reproduce the undeliverable W-2s, you may shred the originals.
However, I would add two important points:
- It's often wise to keep records longer than 4 years, especially if you have concerns about potential audits or employment issues.
- Some states may have different retention requirements, so you should also check your state's specific rules.
I generally recommend keeping these records for 7 years to be on the safe side, unless you're tight on storage space.
You can find a pdf of the current year W4 Employee's Withholding Certificate to download and print at irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fw4.pdf . This employment tax form underwent major revisions in 2020 including the withholding calculation method. It is to be completed by each employee so that you withhold the correct amount of federal income tax.
The IRS has a withholding calculator that employees can use to help fill out the W4 ... especially if:
- an employee has more than one job; or
- an employee is a couple where both are employed; or
- the couple have several children.
This useful tool can be found on the IRS website by searching for "withholding calculator".
Cautionary Note:
Small business owners who handle their own payroll taxes need to be the lookout for these costly mistakes regarding state withholding requirements. Here's what you need to know:
The biggest misconception is assuming that federal Form W-4 automatically works for state withholding. It doesn't. Many states require their own specific withholding forms, and state withholding rules often differ from federal requirements. Using the wrong form can result in:
- Under-withholding, leaving your employees with unexpected tax bills
- Over-withholding, unnecessarily reducing employee take-home pay
- Potential penalties from state tax authorities
- Additional administrative burden to correct errors
While sixteen states like Alabama, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Idaho, Kansas, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina, and Utah as well as the District of Columbia tax jurisdiction accept the federal W-4, twenty-six require state-specific forms. Additionally, state requirements can change annually. Eight states like Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming don't have state income tax, so no state withholding forms are needed.
My Recommendation:
- Contact your state tax authority directly to confirm current requirements.
- Consider using professional payroll services - the cost often outweighs the risk of errors.
- At a minimum, consult with a tax professional to set up your withholding system correctly.
I never realized how lucky we are in Canada that our federal, provincial and territorial Finance Ministers work together to reduce duplication of paperwork for small business owners.
Let's Chat About ...
Employment Tax Forms I-9 and W4
New Hire Paperwork
Employers must report all new hires. On June 11, 2011, the "first day of work" law went into effect. Employers are required to report the date an employee first performs services for pay on tax form I-9, in addition to the other information requirements, which are:
- employee's name
- employee's address
- employee's SSN
- employer's name
- employer's address
- employer's federal EIN
Homeland Security announced that "starting November 1, 2023, all employers must use the revised Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification, with the edition date 08/01/23, when completing the employment eligibility verification process. This updated Form I-9 reflects the option for eligible employers to verify employment eligibility remotely [using the new online I-9 system]" .
COVID-19 remote verification flexibilities ended July 31, 2023. Employers are now required to inspect documents in person for employees whose documents were previously examined remotely.
In general, new hires must be reported no later than 20 days after the date the employer hires the employee. Timeframes vary by state with some requiring less than 20 days. Many states now prefer electronic submission. It is optional, not mandatory. In addition, some states require additional information.
Here is a quick overview of the steps you need to take and employment tax forms you need to complete when you hire a new employee:
- You must verify their work eligibility by completing Form I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification. There is an employee section and an employer section. Both must be completed. The employee must "show original documents that prove the employee's identity and work authorization". You can find the latest version of the Form I-9 at http://www.uscis.gov/i-9.
- Use the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services' E-Verify system at http://www.dhs.gov/e-verify to verify "whether the employee’s name and social security number (SSN) match the government’s records". E-Verify is mandatory in some states but optional in others. It's required for federal contractors.
- Have the employee complete and submit Form W-4 Employee's Withholding Certificate along with your state withholding form if applicable. "If the employee does not complete and submit a Form W-4, withhold federal income tax based on a marital status of “single” and zero withholding." Employees hired before 2020 don't need to complete the new W-4 form unless they want to adjust their withholding.
- "You may ask the employee to show you their Social Security card (and you may photocopy it) to increase the likelihood that the name and SSN that you enter in your payroll records and provide in federal and state reporting (such as Employment Tax Form W-2) are correct."
- Verify the employee's name and SSN online at http://www.ssa.gov/employer/ssnv.htm. There is a registration process to use this service, so think ahead and register in advance. If the employee never gives you a SSN, go to http://www.socialsecurity.gov/employer/critical.htm to find out what to do.
- Report your new hire to "the state in which he or she works shortly after the date of hire". This can usually be done by submitting an electronic copy of the employee's W-4 to the appropriate state agency. It would be prudent for an employer to check their specific state's website for: (i) state withholding forms, (ii) new hire reporting deadlines, and (iii) additional documentation requirements.
- Employers must retain I-9 forms for 3 years after the date of hire or 1 year after employment ends, whichever is later.
My Recommendation:
Employers should consider maintaining a new hire checklist to ensure consistent compliance with all these requirements for each new employee. This is especially helpful for small businesses that hire infrequently and may not have established HR procedures.
New Hire Important Points for Small Business Owners:
- Verify your state's specific reporting window requirements. While federal law allows up to 20 days, many states have shorter time frames. Best practice: Report new hires as soon as possible.
- Use the new I-9 form (edition date 08/01/23) starting November 1, 2023. The old form became invalid after October 31, 2023.
- Follow W-4 requirements correctly. Pre-2020 employees can remain on their existing W-4 forms (grandfather provision) until they want a change, while all new hires must use the revised form.
- Check your state's specific E-Verify requirements. Requirements vary by state location, industry type, and federal contractor status.
- I-9 forms must be kept for 3 years after the hire date or 1 year after termination, whichever is later. Store records securely, preferably with digital backup. Implement a system to track retention periods.
Reference: US Code reference: 42 USC 653a(b)(1)(A) The Public Health and Welfare - State Directory of New Hires "(b) Employer information (1) Reporting requirement (A) In general Except as provided in subparagraphs (B) and (C), each employer shall furnish to the Directory of New Hires of the State in which a newly hired employee works, a report that contains the name, address, and social security number of the employee, and the name and address of, and identifying number assigned under section 6109 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to, the employer."
Best Practices for New Hires
1. Create a new hire checklist as follows:
- W-4
- I-9 with proper ID copies - Form I-9 verifies the identity and employment authorization of individuals hired for employment in the United States.
- State tax forms
- Direct deposit form
- Emergency contact info
2. Keep all forms in separate, secure files.
3. Set up the employee in your payroll system immediately.
Employment Tax Form W-2 The Annual Employee Wage Statement
Please Read Before You Prepare Your W-2 Slips
It is important to remember that for the purpose of tax filing deadlines, income is reported in the year it was paid (cash basis) NOT when the income was earned (accrual basis).
This applies to your mandatory payroll deduction remittances as well as the preparation of the W2 slips.
Do not confuse this with GAAP reporting where you accrue unpaid but earned wage income in the year the wage was earned.
For example: If you pay wages on January 2, 2025 for work done in December 2024, those wages go on the 2025 W-2, not 2024.
The same applies to payroll taxes - they are reported in the period when the payment is made. This includes bonuses too - if you pay 2024 bonuses in January 2025, they're 2025 income
If you are using an accounting software program like QuickBooks Online, it knows the rules and will correctly prepare the W2s provided you have entered your payroll correctly.
It's important and necessary to (i) enter pay dates accurately, (ii) process payroll in the correct period, and (iii) double-check year-end dates, especially for the last payroll of the year.
Overview:
- Shows total wages, taxes withheld, and other compensation on a cash basis (see sidebar).
- Prepare one for each employee by January 31st following the tax year.
- Send Copy A to Social Security Administration by January 31st following the tax year. It is same deadline for both paper and electronic filing.
- Give Copies B, C, and 2 to the employee.
- Keep Copy D for your records.
A W2 Wage and Tax Statement is a summary of the wages and withholdings taken for each employee employed during the year. Employees must receive their W2 employment tax form by January 31st each year.
Employee Payroll Tax Slip Preparation Tip
- Before you prepare your W2s, verify online that each name matches the SSN at Social Security Number Verification Service (SSNVS) at www.socialsecurity.gov/employer/ssnv.htm. Verification is free and highly recommended to avoid filing issues.
- When preparing your W-2 employment tax forms, it is important to remember that for the purpose of tax filing deadlines, income is reported in the year it was paid not when the income was earned.
Do NOT confuse this tax rule with GAAP reporting where you accrue unpaid but earned wage income in the year the wage was earned. This timing difference may require you book a yearend adjusting entry.
- Take precautions to secure employee data. For W-2 employment tax forms, you must show the complete, untruncated SSN on Copy A (sent to Social Security Administration) and Copy 1 (sent to State/City/Local tax departments).
Truncation is a security protection for employees. For identity protection, the IRS actually encourages truncation on employee copies to help prevent identity theft. You CAN and SHOULD truncate SSNs (show as XXX-XX-1234) on Copy B (given to employee for federal tax return), Copy C (employee's record copy), and Copy 2 (employee's state/local tax copy.
- Click here to find IRS General Instructions for the W-2 employment tax form. This web page has links and instructions for the forms; box by box. Make sure you check out the first section called "What's New" to come up to speed about changes you need to be aware of.
If for some reason the link doesn't work ... because they've updated it or renamed it ... at the time of this writing, the location for this employment tax form was: IRS website> Instructions> General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 (2024).
My Recommendation:
To protect employee data in your business, I recommend:
- Keeping W-2 employment tax information in locked files or password-protected digital storage.
- Limiting access to only essential personnel.
- Using secure methods when transmitting W-2 data.
- Shredding old documents containing SSNs.
- Never emailing unencrypted files with full SSNs.
Good To Know
Supplemental Wages
Supplemental wages (like bonuses, commissions, overtime) are included on a W-2 employment tax form in:
- Box 1 (Wages, tips, other compensation)
- Box 2 (Federal income tax withheld - including the 22% supplemental wage withholding)
- Box 3 (Social Security wages, up to the annual limit)
- Box 5 (Medicare wages)
Important note: While supplemental wages are withheld at different rates during the year, on the W-2 employment tax form, they're combined with regular wages. There's no separate reporting required for supplemental wages; they're simply part of the total wages reported.
For your small business, you'll want to ensure your payroll system properly tracks these supplemental payments throughout the year for accurate W-2 employment tax form reporting in January.
There are 3 procedures used to determine the amount of withholding on supplemental wages:
- Manadatory flat rate withholding (37%) applies to supplemental wages over $1 million in a calendar year. It must be used for amounts exceeding $1 million.
- Optional flat rate withholding (22%) can be used for supplemental wages under $1 million. This is the most common and simplest method for small businesses. Examples: bonuses, commissions, overtime pay.
- The aggregrate procedure combines supplemental wages with regular wages. It calculates withholding as if total amount was a single payment. It is more complex but can be more accurate. It must be used if an employee has no regular wages to base withholding on.
For a small business with less than 10 employees, the Optional Flat Rate (22%) is typically the most practical method for handling supplemental wage withholding, unless you have a specific reason to use the aggregate procedure.
See The Department of Treasury's INFO 2012-0063 for more information. While the reference is somewhat dated, the basic procedures remain unchanged. Current guidance is regularly updated and can be found in these sources on supplemental wage withholding:
- IRS Publication 15 (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guide
- Internal Revenue Code Section 3402(h)(2)
- Treasury Regulations 31.3402(g)-1
The Bookkeeper's Tip
A Good Bookkeeping Practice
Employment Tax Forms
Yearend W-2 Reconciliation
Due Date: January 31st whether you file electronically* or by paper
As part of your year-end employee payroll tax procedures, reconcile your Form 941 to your Form W-2. The IRS looks for the following discrepancies:
- Bonuses are reported as wages and as social security and Medicare wages on Forms W-2 and on Form 941;
- Social security and medicare wages and taxes are reported separately on Forms W-2 and on Form 941 ... social security taxes W-2 Box 4; medicare taxes W-2 Box 6 ... do not include taxes in wages information W-2 Box 3 and 5;
- Social security wages should not exceed the annual wage base amount;
- Do not report tax free noncash wages as social security and medicare wages;
- Take the time to check that all W-2s total to the amounts reported on Form W-3.
Additional Important Points:
- Quarterly Reconciliation: The best practice is to reconcile quarterly 941s with payroll records throughout the year. Don't wait until year-end to catch discrepancies.
- Common Areas to Check: Check third-party sick pay, group term life insurance over $50,000, personal use of company vehicle, tips, health insurance for 2% S-corporation shareholders
- State Requirements: Don't forget state unemployment wage bases. State W-2 filing requirements may differ.
- Record Retention: Keep W-2 records for at least 4 years. Maintain backup documentation for all adjustments.
- Electronic Filing Requirements: E-filing is mandatory if you have 250+ W-2s. Consider e-filing even if not required - it's more efficient.
* Early Filing Note:
The IRS has NOT prohibited early filing completely; even if all W-2, W2G and 1099-R forms have not yet been received. However, beginning with tax year 2023 (filing in 2024), they implemented new procedures:
- The IRS began accepting and processing tax returns on January 29, 2024. The 2025 date has not been released yet.
- Tax preparers CAN submit returns before receiving all W-2s and 1099s, but it's not recommended. It could delay processing and it might increase audit risk. They're a chance it could result in having to file an amended return.
Best Practices For Small Business Owners:
- Wait until you have ALL tax documents before filing.
- Match received forms against expected forms.
- Verify amounts against your records.
- Keep copies of all tax documents.
Reminder for a Small Business with Less Than 10 Employees:
- You must provide W-2s to employees by January 31st.
- You should encourage your employees to wait for all tax documents before filing.
- Keep good records of all 1099s you receive from vendors and issue to contractors.
Source: section 12 of Pub. 15 (Circular E)
Employment Tax Form W-3 The Transmittal Form
Overview:
- This is your 'cover sheet' that totals all W-2 employment tax forms.
- Submit this with W-2s to Social Security Administration (by January 31st following the tax year).
- The same date applies whether you file electronically or by paper.
- Must match your quarterly 941 forms for the year (or annual Form 944).
The W3 Transmittal of Wage and Tax Statements is a summary of all the W2s submitted to Social Security Administration (SSA).
SSA ... not IRS ... used to require they receive their copies of all the W2s along with the W3 summary by February 28 each year. However, in 2017, the due date moved to January 31 to combat tax refund fraud and identity theft. Previously, the IRS would often issue refunds before they could verify the wage information on taxpayers' returns against the W-2s and W-3s from employers (since those weren't due until February 28th). Identity thieves took advantage of this gap by filing fraudulent tax returns early in the season, claiming refunds before the IRS could match the information with employer forms.
Now you really need to have all your ducks in a row to meet the January 31st deadline. Start your year-end payroll reconciliation process early to ensure you can meet this deadline comfortably.
Important Requirements:
- If you have 250 or more W-2s, you must file electronically
- The W-3 totals must match with the total of your 4 quarterly amounts reported on Form 941 during the year (or annual Form 944).
- All amounts reported on the W-2s must match the totals reported on the W-3.
Filing Options:
- Electronic filing through SSA's Business Services Online (BSO)
- Paper filing (if fewer than 250 W-2s)
Common Errors to Avoid:
- Mismatched totals between W-2s and W-3
- Incorrect employer identification numbers
- Missing or incorrect SSA registration number
- Mathematical errors in totaling fields
Resources:
- Current instructions are available at www.ssa.gov/employer
- IRS Publication 393 (Federal Employment Tax Forms)
- SSA's Business Services Online Tutorial
Click here to find IRS General Instructions for Form W-3. This web page has links and instructions for the forms; box by box. Make sure you check out the first section called "What's New" to come up to speed about changes you need to be aware of.
If for some reason the link doesn't work ... because they've updated it or renamed it ... at the time of this writing, the location was: IRS website> Instructions> General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 (2024).
The Bookkeeper's Tip
A Good Bookkeeping Practice
Employment Tax Forms
Yearend W-3 Reconciliation
Due Date: January 31st whether you file electronically or by paper
Take the time to check that all W-2s total to the amounts reported on Form W-3.
As part of your year-end employee payroll tax procedures, reconcile your Form 941 to your Form W-3. The IRS and/or SSA cross check the following amounts:
- W-3 Box 1 Wages, tips and other compensation = line 2 on sum of quarterly Form 941s;
- W-3 Box 2 Federal income tax withholding = line 3 on sum of quarterly Form 941s;
- W-3 Box 3 Social security wages = line 5a on sum of quarterly Form 941s ... do not report prior year Form 941 adjustments on the current year Form W-3;
- W-3 Box 5 Medicare wages and tips = line 5c on sum of quarterly Form 941s ... do not report prior year Form 941 adjustments on the current year Form W-3;
- W-3 Box 7 Social security tips = of line 5b on sum of
quarterly Form 941s ... do
not report prior year Form 941 adjustments on the current year Form
W-3;
This reconciliation process is essential because discrepancies between these forms often trigger IRS notices and potential penalties. Let's look at a few key points:
- Start the reconciliation process early - don't wait until January to begin.
- Double-check that your payroll software or service has properly categorized all compensation types.
- If any mid-year adjustments to Form 941s were made, ensure these are properly reflected.
- Remember that some items, like third-party sick pay, might need special attention in the reconciliation process.
Source: section 12 of Pub. 15 (Circular E), General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3
Employment Tax Forms Reconciliation Tips
1. Monthly:
- Compare payroll reports to bank statements
- Verify tax deposits match payroll tax liabilities
2. Quarterly:
- Match Form 941 totals to payroll reports
- Verify state unemployment reports match payroll
3. Annually:
- W-2 Box 1 wages should match 941 line 2
- W-3 totals must match sum of all W-2s
- W-3 must reconcile with all four quarterly 941s
Red Flags To Watch For
- W-2 totals don't match 941s
- Tax deposits don't match liabilities
- Missing or incomplete employee forms
Small Business Year-End Payroll Tasks
Tasks Summary:
1. Understanding Key Deadlines
2. Verify Employee Information
3. Review Wage and Tax Data
4. Process Final Payroll Adjustments
5. Prepare for the New Year
6. Data Backup
7. Best Practices
8. Additional Important Steps to Consider
9. Cautionary Note
10. Common Pitfalls to Avoid
11. Getting Help When Needed
12. Reliable Sources for Checklists
1. Understanding Key Deadlines
The IRS and state agencies have strict deadlines for year-end payroll reporting. Mark these dates on your calendar:
- January 31: W-2s and 1099s must be distributed to employees and contractors
- January 31: File Employment Tax Forms W-2 and W-3 with the Social Security Administration
- January 31: File Form 941* for the fourth quarter
- Various state-specific deadlines for unemployment and other reports vary
* It is important that Quarterly Form 941 due dates must be met throughout the year.
Meeting the SSA/IRS year-end payroll deadlines is crucial for several reasons:
- Avoidance of Penalties: Missing the deadlines for filing W-2s, 1099s, and other tax forms can result in financial penalties, sometimes significant ones. The IRS and SSA impose fines for late submissions, which can quickly add up and affect your business’s financial health.
- Professional Reputation: As a business owner, meeting deadlines builds trust with your employees, vendors, and regulators.
- Timely Tax Reporting: Employees rely on receiving their W-2s on time to file their personal tax returns. Meeting the deadline ensures your employees can meet their own tax obligations without delay.
- Smooth Year-End Process: Keeping on schedule helps streamline your year-end process, reducing last-minute stress and potential errors that can occur when rushing to meet deadlines.
- Compliance with Laws: Adhering to these deadlines helps ensure you are in compliance with federal regulations. Compliance reduces audit risks and potential legal issues that might arise from noncompliance.
Ensuring you meet these deadlines maintains financial order and legal standing and contributes to the long-term health and reputation of your business. If you encounter challenges, seeking assistance from a CPA or payroll professional is prudent.
2. Verify Employee Information
Here are the steps to verify and confirm information for your employees. I am assuming you are using an online payroll application:
1. Verify the Employee Names, Addresses, SSNs:
- Log in to your accounting program and go to the 'Employees' or 'Payroll' module.
- Check each employee's profile to verify their name, address, and SSN against their Social Security card and other official documents. I like to run a report that provides employee details rather than doing the review in real time as there are too many interruptions during a day.
- If any information is incorrect, update it in the payroll module.
2. Verify the Employee Status of Terminations and New Hires:
- Use the 'Employee Status' or similar feature to view recent updates, such as new hires or employee terminations.
- Ensure you have employment documentation for new hires and employee terminations paperwork for those who have left on file.
- Revise the employee's status as active, terminated, or another relevant status categories as needed.
3. Review Classification of Employees vs. Contractors:
- Check job descriptions and responsibilities to ensure correct classification.
- Ensure contractors have signed agreements outlining their independent contractor status.
- Use your software to distinguish between employees and contractors. For example, in QuickBooks Online, contractors are found in the Accounts Payable module while employees are located in the Payroll module.
4. Benefit Elections and Deductions:
- Go to the 'Benefits' or 'Deductions area in your payroll program.
- Verify the benefit elections made by employees, such as health insurance plans. Again I like to work off of reports.
- Ensure deductions are correctly set up and reflect any benefit elections requested by employees.
- Make any necessary changes to benefit details or deduction amounts.
It's important to note that many of these verifications can be integrated into your onboarding and exit processes. A proactive approach not only reduces your work load during the year-end review, it also ensures continuous accuracy throughout the year. Once you have procedures and processes in place, only routine checks should be required.
For example, implement standardized checklists for onboarding and exiting to ensure all necessary steps and verifications are consistently applied. Conducting a quarterly or semi-annual review for data accuracy allows for any necessary adjustments in a manageable time frame.
By having procedures in place and regularly reviewing this information, you can maintain accurate employee records as well as ensuring audit ready compliance with the numerous employment and tax regulations.
3. Review Wage and Tax Data
Accuracy is crucial when dealing with payroll. In general you want to reconcile all quarterly 941s with your payroll records. This is done by ensuring these three things match - (i) your payroll reports, (ii) your bank statements disbursements, and (iii) your Form 941 reporting to the IRS.
For example, if your Q4 Form 941 shows you paid $50,000 in total wages, your payroll reports should show $50,000 in wages, your bank statements should show these payments, and your IRS account should show the related tax deposits. If these don't match, you need to find out why. It could be a timing difference, data entry error, or missed deposit.
Here's how I suggest you do this in more detail:
1. Verifying total wages paid:
- Start by printing or downloading detailed payroll reports from your accounting software. This should include gross wages for each employee.
- Add up the gross wages for the period you're reviewing (quarterly or annually) and ensure the total matches the sum reported on your Form 941.
- Cross-check these totals against your bank statements to verify that the wages paid out align with what's reported.
2. Confirming federal, state, and local tax withholdings:
- Use your accounting software to generate a payroll tax summary report which outlines all tax withholdings.
- Cross-reference these figures with the amounts reported on your quarterly Form 941 (Federal) and any state/local tax reports.
- If there are discrepancies, review any notices or correspondence from tax authorities for payments received or adjustment notices.
3. Reconciling quarterly 941 reports with W-2 employment tax forms totals:
- Gather all four Form 941s. Access payroll registers from your accounting software. Retrieve W-2 employment tax forms for your employees.
- Sum up wages, federal taxes withheld, Social Security, and Medicare from each Form 941 to get annual totals. Ensure these annual figures match the corresponding boxes on the W-2s (Box 1 for wages, Box 2 for federal tax, etc.).
- Look for mismatches between Form 941 totals and W-2s employment tax forms. Check for common errors like timing differences or manual adjustments. Make necessary corrections in your software.
- Verify that any discrepancies are addressed. Make sure the final W-2s reflect the corrected totals from your reports.
- Confirm tax payments align with liabilities reported on 941s.
4. Checking that fringe benefits are properly reported:
- Verify what fringe benefits you offer to employees (e.g., health insurance, retirement contributions) and ensure these are properly documented in your payroll system.
- Check how these benefits impact gross wages and tax calculations. For example, ensure that any taxable benefits are added to an employee’s gross wages and that the correct taxes are withheld.
- Generate a benefits report from your accounting system to ensure the benefits match what is reported on the employees' W-2 forms at year-end.
Here’s a breakdown of what you need to consider regarding fringe benefits and their correct reporting:
- Fringe benefits are additional compensation provided to employees on top of their regular salary or wages. These can include health insurance, retirement plan contributions, employee discounts, use of a company vehicle, educational assistance, and more.
- For your business, correctly reporting fringe benefits is important for determining your tax deductions. Some fringe benefits are tax-deductible business expenses, but the way they are reported can affect your overall tax liabilities.
- Fringe benefits might be taxable income for the employee. For example, if you provide a company car for personal use, it could add to the employee's taxable income, affecting their tax withholdings and liabilities.
- Ensure that all fringe benefits are accurately reported on your payroll system and on employees' W-2 forms. This includes determining whether the benefit is taxable or non-taxable. The IRS provides detailed guidelines on which benefits are taxable and how to calculate their fair market value.
- Some benefits, like certain health insurance premiums or contributions to retirement accounts, may be exempt from taxes. However, they still must be reported correctly to ensure compliance with tax regulations.
- It’s important to accurately value the benefits provided to employees. For example, if you provide a company car, you need to calculate the value of its personal use accurately based on IRS guidelines.
- Maintain accurate records of all fringe benefits provided. This is essential not just for reporting but also for substantiating tax deductions in the event of an audit.
- Consider consulting with a CPA or tax advisor to ensure compliance with all federal and state tax laws regarding fringe benefits. They can help identify which benefits are taxable and assist with proper reporting.
By ensuring that all fringe benefits are reported correctly, you help avoid potential issues with tax liabilities for both your business and your employees. Compliance with IRS regulations is essential to prevent penalties and to optimize your tax positions.
5. Ensuring special payments (bonuses, awards) are correctly classified:
- Record special payments such as bonuses or awards separately in your accounting system. Use specific accounts to track these payments.
- Understand the tax implications of these payments. Typically, bonuses and awards are subject to the same withholdings as regular wages and should be included in gross wages on payroll reports.
- Review individual pay stubs for special payments to confirm they have been taxed correctly and included in reported totals.
General Best Practices For A Business With Less Than 10 Employees:
1. Larger companies schedule periodic internal audits of their payroll system throughout the year to catch discrepancies early. However, having strong onboarding and exiting processes in place, as well as regular monthly reconciliations, conducting a detailed review of your payroll system only at year-end might indeed be sufficient for your small business. But start early, so any corrections can be made before December 31st. That said, you need these processes in place:
- Strong onboarding ensures new hires are properly set up in your payroll system from the beginning. Well-managed exiting processes helps to make sure the final pay, benefits, and tax documents are handled correctly for departing employees. Adhering to theses processes help reduce errors throughout the year.
- You need to perform monthly reconciliations. Monthly reconciliations mean you're keeping a close eye on your records consistently. This regular monitoring helps catch and address discrepancies quickly, minimizing the risk of significant year-end issues.
- Year-end procedures, when combined with the ongoing diligence discussed above, can be more efficient than conducting a full audit multiple times a year, especially for a small team. It allows you to consolidate efforts and focus resources where they're most needed.
- With a small employee base of less than 10 employees, the volume of transactions is relatively low, which makes a single, comprehensive year-end review manageable without compromising accuracy or compliance.
- As long as tax filings, payroll reporting, and benefit administration are done correctly on a monthly basis, the year-end review serves primarily to ensure everything aligns before you finalize reports and filings, like W-2s and 1099s.
2. It's important to ensure your accounting and payroll software work seamlessly together. If you use QuickBooks Online and subscribe to their payroll module, you shouldn't have an issue. Integration is a real time-saver for small businesses. It helps owners avoid the headache of manual data entry errors. By reducing manual data entry mistakes, you not only automate and streamline your processes but you also minimize payroll discrepancies and compliance issues that could otherwise cause major headaches down the line. QBO Payroll has direct deposit of pay checks as well as the option to setup auto payment of your payroll taxes to the government. I like that it removes a things off my 'to-do' list.
3. Think about consulting with a CPA, tax advisor, or payroll professional, especially when dealing with unique payroll situations or complex benefit structures. Some examples requiring guidance would be benefits, new tax laws, or uncommon situations (such as employee stock options or multi-state employment scenarios). This is especially helpful for small businesses that likely don't employ an in-house tax expert like large companies do.
By establishing and maintaining consistent and meticulous payroll records as well as relying on your payroll program, you can efficiently manage and verify all aspects of payroll reporting.
4. Process Final Payroll Adjustments
The adjustments referred to in this task require careful documentation to maintain compliance with the IRS and other regulatory agencies. I know I've already said this, but if you are unsure, chat with your professional bookkeeper or CPA to ensure all these adjusting entries are correctly processed.
The instructions I'm providing below are oversimplified but should get you started in the right direction. Don't forget to take notes every time you go through this process, especially if you learn something new while performing these tasks.
1. Holiday bonuses or special payments:
- Enter the bonus as an additional payroll item in your accounting software.
- Ensure appropriate tax withholdings are applied, similar to regular wages.
- Categorize the payment under employee compensation in your records.
2. Third-party sick pay:
(See also Task 8.3 'Additional Important Steps to Consider' for more information on this topic)
- If a third party, like an insurance company, pays sick wages, record the payment in your payroll records.
- Include it on the employee’s W-2 employment tax form under appropriate boxes for reporting.
- Ensure FICA taxes are accounted for according to IRS guidelines.
3. Expense reimbursements:
- Record the reimbursement as a non-payroll expense entry, as it is not taxable income.
- Ensure the reimbursement is properly documented and attached to a specific business expense.
4. Taxable fringe benefits:
(See additional notes about fringe benefits under task 3.4.)
- Add the value of the benefit to the employee’s compensation in your software.
- Calculate and withhold the correct taxes (income, Social Security, and Medicare).
- Report this on the employee’s W-2 as additional wages.
5. Void or canceled checks from throughout the year:
- In the banking module of your accounting software, void the check entry and ensure the associated payments are reversed.
- Check the adjustment is reflected in your bank reconciliation.
5. Prepare for the New Payroll Year
The following tasks will help ensure audit compliant payroll records and keep your processes streamlined. If questions or complexities arise, reaching out to support from your software provider or a CPA for advice is always a good idea. Setting up your payroll program for a new year:
1. Review updated tax tables:
- Login to your accounting program and go to the payroll module.
- Look for an option related to tax settings or tables.
- Compare the tax tables with the latest IRS and state tax rate publications to ensure they are up to date.
- If your software offers automatic updates, ensure that feature is enabled for tax tables.
2. Implement new minimum wage requirements:
- Identify new wage regulations applicable to your state or federal jurisdiction.
- Update your payroll settings in the software to reflect any new minimum wage requirements.
- Communicate changes to your employees, especially if their wages will be adjusted.
- Make sure all future payroll runs reflect these new wage rates. As far as I know, QuickBooks Online (in Canada at least) does not have a batch edit feature to hand minimum wage changes. It all has to be done by individual employees. (Wow. Automation? Not!)
3. Update payroll software and planning for benefit/regulatory changes:
- Regularly check for software updates and patches; most systems prompt you when updates are available.
- Read any release notes to understand what changes or fixes are included.
- Stay informed on any upcoming regulatory changes through newsletters from your accounting software provider or relevant government bulletins.
- Use the planning tools or resources within your software to simulate the impact of changes in benefits or regulations on your business finances.
6. Backup Data
Regularly backing up your payroll (and accounting) data is a best practice. Here's my suggestion for managing your payroll data backups:
- Schedule regular automatic backups. If you use QuickBooks Online, A Rewind subscription automatically backs up your company file. If you have QBO Advance, it has a backup system included. I'm hoping Intuit will extend the service to other subscription levels in the future.
- Make sure backups are stored in a secure, accessible format. Don't forget one simple backup option is to print PDF copies of your payroll reports as part of your backup plan.
- Use reliable cloud storage solutions that offer encryption and multi-factor authentication for added security.
- Don't forget to periodically test your backups to ensure data integrity and accessibility. For example, you don't want to find out your backup hasn't been working when you are trying to restore the data after a hard dive failure.
- Keep multiple backup copies in different locations. I like the 3-2-2 backup strategy recommended by IT professionals today. Keep 3 copies of your data, store 2 copies locally but on different devices, and 2 copies offsite. One copy should be in a remote location and the other copy in the cloud or both copies are in the cloud but on other sides of the country. As Citynet.net says, "Securing your data and network from day-to-day threats is a core foundation of our business.". Just remember the general rule is you want your payroll data in more than one secure place.
In light of unexpected events like the December 2024 sudden closure of the trusted accounting software provider Bench Accounting, backing up your payroll (and accounting) data is absolutely critical. Here are some key points to consider before you decide to skip this task:
- If your accounting service provider suddenly shuts down like Bench Accounting did, you need immediate access to your financial records to manage your business operations effectively. Without backups, you risk losing access to crucial financial data that are essential for day-to-day operations, financial reporting, and tax compliance.
- Unexpected events like software shutdowns, cyber-attacks, or technical issues can disrupt your business. Backing up your data regularly reduces these risks by keeping a secure copy stored elsewhere or on a platform you manage.
- Businesses must keep financial records to meet to legal and tax requirements. Without backups, they risk non-compliance if audited, potentially resulting in penalties or other legal issues.
- As your business grows, you may need to switch to a new accounting system. Having a good backup will make the move much smoother. Backups help keep your data safe and ensures nothing gets lost or messed up during the switch. Trust me something always goes wrong during a conversion to a new system.
- Historical financial data is really important for making smart business decisions and planning ahead. If you lose this data, it will be tough to see how your business was doing, assess performance trends, and create accurate five year business plans.
- Lastly, having a backup of your financial records gives you peace of mind. It allows you to concentrate on running your business without stressing about losing data that could disrupt your work.
7. Best Practices
- Schedule a detailed payroll review
- Verify all software updates manually
- Consider state-specific requirements
- Maintain organized documentation system
- Address issues promptly as they arise throughout the year
8. Additional Important Steps to Consider
- Verify all bonus payments, fringe benefits, and taxable non-cash compensation are properly recorded before year-end.
- Review overtime calculations for the year to ensure compliance with FLSA regulations.
- If applicable, check that all third-party sick pay has been properly recorded and reported.
Third party sick pay are payments made to your employees for sick time or disability by someone other than you (the employer). The most common example is when you have a disability insurance policy for your employees, and the insurance company pays your employees directly when they're sick or disabled.
Here's what you need to know:
1. These payments are typically taxable wages.
2. They must be reported on the employee's W-2.
3. You're still responsible for the employer portion of FICA taxes.
4. The insurance company should provide you with statements showing these payments.
The tricky part comes with tax reporting. Sometimes the third party (insurance company) handles all the tax withholding and reporting. Other times, you need to include these payments in your payroll reporting. It depends on your arrangement with the insurance company.
- Verify state unemployment insurance rates for the new year.
- State unemployment insurance agencies typically send rate notices by mail or make them available online. Check your email.
- Go to the official website of your state’s department of labor or unemployment insurance agency. Many states provide rate lookup tools or post rate notices for employers online.
- Once you have your new SUI rate, log into your online accounting software. Enter your new state unemployment insurance rate so future payroll calculations will be accurate.
- If you haven't received your rate or can't find it online, consider contacting your state’s unemployment insurance agency directly for assistance.
- Keep a copy of the rate notice for your records, as you may need it for reference or verification.
- Review any special COVID-related credits or deferrals if still applicable.
9. Cautionary Notes
A. While payroll software does typically update automatically, sometimes updates aren't applied correctly. Always verify key numbers independently, especially for:
- Social Security wage base
- Federal unemployment tax (FUTA) wage base
- State unemployment insurance rates and wage bases
- Updated minimum wage rates (federal and state)
B. Backing up your payroll data is critical. Recently, Bench Accounting closed without notice on December 27, 2024 after 13 years in business. Clients were locked out as the platform was shut down. Fortunately, Employer.com acquired the company on December 30, 2024 and clients once again had access to their data. This is never a good thing, but the timing just before the end of the year could have disastrous. In all fairness, Bench Accounting was making arrangements with clients to access their data to transition to another platform. Still ...
10. Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Watch out for these frequent mistakes:
- Missing deadlines for tax deposits
- Incorrect employee classifications
- Miscalculating overtime pay
- Forgetting to include taxable fringe benefits
- Improper handling of final paychecks
11. Getting Help When Needed
Reach out for expert help if you:
- Are unsure about complex calculations
- Have special situations like multi-state employees
- Need help with regulatory compliance
- Want to ensure accuracy in reporting
12. Reliable Sources for Checklists
- IRS Website: The IRS provides comprehensive tax guides for businesses, including annual updates to tax forms and filing requirements ([IRS.gov](https://www.irs.gov)).
- American Payroll Association (APA): Offers resources and checklists for payroll management but I find you need to be a member to access the information ([American Payroll Association](https://www.americanpayroll.org)).
- State-specific Tax Websites: Visit your state’s department of revenue or taxation website for state-specific details and requirements.
- Professional Accounting Firms and Payroll Organizations: Many CPA firms as well as reputable payroll companies like ADP publish year-end checklists and guides on their websites, often freely accessible.
Payroll regulations change frequently. It is prudent to check in with your professional bookkeeper, CPA or payroll service provider to ensure all your bases are covered. This task list and the check list below ensures nothing has been overlooked before moving forward with next year's payroll setup. It's much easier to catch and correct any issues now rather than discovering them after beginning the new year's payroll processing.
Small Business Year-End Payroll Checklist
For 10 or Fewer Employees
As a small business owner in the U.S., ensuring you have all your payroll tasks completed by year-end is very, very, very important. It's always best to refer to specific resources like ADP's Annual Payroll Year-End Checklist or consult with a CPA for tailored guidance.
That said, here's a general checklist for year-end payroll for a business with 10 or fewer employees, valid for either the 2023 or 2024 tax year.
1. Verify Employee Information and Classification:
- ⎕ Verify accuracy of names, addresses, and SSNs
- ⎕ Confirm employee classifications (full-time/part-time)
- ⎕ Review contractor vs. employee status
- ⎕ Review exempt vs. non-exempt status*
- ⎕ Update outdated W-4 forms
- ⎕ Confirm employee benefit elections for new year
*Paylocity.com explains that "exempt employees usually hold administrative, professional, or executive positions. They're “exempt” from the Fair Labor Standards Act's (FLSA) overtime regulations and, therefore, not entitled to overtime pay. Nonexempt employees are typically paid hourly and perform more manual or technical duties.".
2. Reconcile Payroll Records:
- ⎕ Check point - do your payroll records match your quarterly 941 forms; discrepancies can indicate errors that need to be rectified.
- ⎕ Verify the taxable wages for each employee, double-checking for any mistakes that could affect both tax reporting and employee take-home pay.
- ⎕ Go through overtime payments to ensure they are not only processed correctly but also accurately reflect hours worked and rates. Check they comply with labor laws.
- ⎕ Ensure that any manual checks issued outside the regular payroll system have been accurately recorded in your payroll system and your general ledger. Make sure the correct withholdings were taken and W-2 reporting was not affected incorrectly. It's generally okay to issue manual checks occasionally for special circumstances, such as bonuses, corrections, or other off-cycle payments. However, relying on manual checks regularly can complicate your payroll records and increase the risk of errors.
- ⎕ Confirm that all fringe benefits are reported correctly. The IRS in Publication 15-B define fringe benefits as "a form of pay for the performance of services. For example, you provide an employee with a fringe benefit when you allow the employee to use a business vehicle to commute to and from work." Some fringe benefits are deductible to the employer; some are taxable income for the employee. Check the IRS guidance on which benefits are taxable and how to calculate their fair market value. See task 3.4 above for more information.
- ⎕ If applicable, review any special wage payments such as tips or 401(k) contributions to ensure they comply with regulations and have supporting documentation.
3. Tax Compliance and Reconciliation:
- ⎕ Double check your federal, state, and local tax deposits for accuracy and completeness.
- ⎕ Make sure that all payments made to the IRS on a quarterly or monthly basis have been properly entered in your accounting program.
- ⎕ Take time to reconcile Social Security and Medicare withholdings with your IRS account to avoid any potential issues.
- ⎕ Confirm the state unemployment insurance rates that will apply in the coming year; you may need to make adjustments to your upcoming budget.
- ⎕ To make sure you avoid penalties and are 'audit ready', review your local tax obligations so there are no surprises.
- ⎕ Address any outstanding tax notices or discrepancies you may have received, as resolving issues in a timely manner is extremely important when dealing with payroll.
4. Year-end Review of Benefits:
- ⎕ Take a look at your records for paid time off to ensure it aligns with employee usage policies.
- ⎕ If applicable, confirm the amounts contributed to health insurance plans to maintain accurate financial tracking.
- ⎕ Validate the details of contributions made to retirement plans; accuracy is important for both taxation and employee satisfaction.
5. Year-end Tax Forms:
- ⎕ Prepare W-2s for employees
- ⎕ Prepare 1099s for contractors - in a larger company, Form 1099 tasks would be performed by Accounts Payable staff and not Payroll staff.
- ⎕ Collect W-9s from contractors
- ⎕ Plan for January 31 distribution deadline
6. System Updates for New Year:
- ⎕ Update your payroll system for the new tax tables
- ⎕ Review minimum wage changes and update manually if your system doesn't handle this for you
- ⎕ Set up new vacation and paid time off (PTO) accruals
- ⎕ Verify software updates
7. Record Keeping:
- ⎕ Back up all payroll data
- ⎕ Store copies of tax filings
- ⎕ Maintain records of paid leave
- ⎕ Address any garnishments or levies
- ⎕ Keep records for at least 4 years
My Recommendations For Independent Contractors
- Get a W-9 completed and signed BEFORE the first payment is made. The W-9 gives you their correct Tax ID/SSN and verifies their business name and address. Keep this in your files.
- It is strongly recommended you have a written contract. It would be prudent to have it reviewed by a lawyer. It should include the scope of work, payment terms, project deadlines, independent contractor status clearly stated, both parties have signed. Keep a copy for your records.
- Keep detailed payment records. Track ALL payments to each IC. If you pay an IC $600+ in a year, you MUST issue a 1099-NEC. Keep receipts/invoices from IC.
- Set a calendar reminder for the 1099 deadline. Prepare 1099-NECs by January 31st. Copy A to IRS. Copy B to contractor. Keep Copy C for your records.
- Tax form 1096 (similar to a W-3, but for 1099s). Submit to IRS with Copy A of 1099s.
- Consider using a 1099 filing service.
Warning Flag
If IRS reclassifies an IC as employee, you're liable for back payroll taxes, penalties, interest, and benefits.
More >> Independent Contractor Rules
Final Thoughts
Regular payroll procedures and year-end payroll processing doesn't have to be overwhelming. By following these guidelines and staying organized, you can successfully keep on top of your payroll responsibilities throughout the year. This will aid in a smooth close out of your payroll year and starting your new year on solid footing. Remember, accuracy now prevents headaches later.
Pro Tip: Consider implementing a payroll software system if you haven't already. It can automate many of these tasks and reduce the likelihood of errors.
Need Help?
If you're feeling overwhelmed with year-end payroll tasks, consider working with a qualified professional bookkeeper who does payroll, a CPA or payroll professional. The cost of professional assistance often outweighs the potential penalties and stress of making mistakes.
This concludes my chat on employment tax forms.
My sincere gratitude to all my readers ... without you I'd have no website. Blessings to you all. My suggestion to you ... enjoy a tall cool glass of lemon water while you click and poke and peek and snoop this site ... perhaps start with the blog which lists the most recent updated articles.
I Hope You Enjoy Your Visit Today,
Your Tutor